Yes, a small number of residents did stay on Sanibel Island during Hurricane Ian in September 2022, despite the mandatory evacuation orders. Survivors described a harrowing experience as the storm surge, which reached up to 12–15 feet, completely inundated the ground floors of almost every structure. Those who stayed had to retreat to second stories or even attics; some reported having to swim between houses or cling to trees as the current from the Gulf of Mexico swept across the island. The destruction of the Sanibel Causeway during the storm meant these survivors were completely cut off from the mainland until the Coast Guard and Urban Search and Rescue teams arrived via helicopter and boat the following day. By 2026, the island has made a significant recovery, but the stories of those who stayed remain a sobering reminder of the power of storm surges, as many of those survivors lost every possession they owned and faced life-threatening conditions for over 12 hours.