You've really got three ways to get from the St Thomas cruise port to Magens Bay: expensive private excursion, hiring a taxi, or renting a car and driving yourself. The taxi fare from the cruise port to Magens Bay is between $10-$15 per person. Taxis are not private taxis–they are more like big, open-top buses.

As of 2026, taxi fares in St. Thomas are strictly regulated and typically charged per person. From the Crown Bay Cruise Port, a taxi to Magens Bay costs approximately $18.00 for a single passenger or $15.00 per person if you are traveling in a group of two or more. If you are departing from the Havensight (WICO) Cruise Port, the fare is slightly lower, usually around $15.00 for one person or $12.00 per person for groups. It is important to note that most St. Thomas taxis are shared "Safari" buses, meaning you will likely ride with other cruise passengers. In addition to the base fare, there is a standard $3.00 fee per bag for luggage, though standard beach bags are usually exempt. Most drivers accept cash (USD), and while some have started using digital payments in 2026, it is highly recommended to carry exact change to ensure a smooth and quick transfer to one of the world's most beautiful beaches.