"Nicer" is subjective, but in 2026, the consensus among travelers is a trade-off between scenic luxury and authentic accessibility. Positano is widely considered the more "visually stunning" town; its vertical, pastel-colored houses clinging to the cliffs make it the most photographed spot on the coast. It is the peak of Amalfi Coast luxury, filled with high-end boutiques and romantic, upscale dining. However, it is notoriously expensive and involves climbing thousands of stairs. Amalfi is "nicer" for those who want a more lived-in, historic atmosphere. It is the transport hub of the coast, making it much easier (and flatter) to navigate, especially for families. It feels more like a real Italian town where "nonnas" hang laundry next to historic cathedrals. If you want a glamorous, "once-in-a-lifetime" romantic splurge, choose Positano. If you want a more authentic, budget-friendly, and practical home base to explore Ravello and Atrani, Amalfi is the superior choice.