The cost of renting a car in Tuscany in 2026 is highly variable and depends heavily on the season, transmission type, and booking window. During the "Low Season" (November–March), you can find small manual cars for as little as €10–€30 per day. However, in the "Peak Season" (July–August), prices for the same vehicles often jump to €60–€100+ per day. One of the biggest factors for American or Australian travelers is the transmission; automatic cars are less common in Italy and can command a premium of €20–€50 extra per day compared to manual versions. Additionally, "one-way fees"—where you pick up in Rome and drop off in Florence—can add €50–€150 to your total. Insurance is another cost to consider; while basic CDW is often included, "Full Coverage" can double the daily rate but is highly recommended to avoid the €1,000–€2,000 security holds typical of Italian rental agencies. Overall, Tuscany is moderately priced for car rentals compared to Northern Europe, but booking at least 2–4 weeks in advance is essential to secure the best rates.