If you're planning a beach vacation then Malta is your best choice. As a smaller island, you can base yourself in one town, like Sliema, and still explore a different beach each day. Despite Malta being a better beach destination, I think Sicily is overall a more scenic island with more natural beauty.

In 2026, the choice between Malta and Sicily depends on your available time and transport preferences. If you have less than a week and want a car-free holiday, Malta is the winner. It is a compact archipelago where you can base yourself in Valletta or Sliema and reach world-class diving sites and megalithic temples within 30 minutes via bus or ferry. English is a primary language, making it exceptionally easy to navigate. Conversely, if you have 10 to 14 days, Sicily offers a much deeper, more varied experience. It is the Mediterranean's largest island and requires a car to truly appreciate the Valley of the Temples in Agrigento, the volcanic landscapes of Mount Etna, and the baroque beauty of Noto. Sicily has a superior culinary scene (arancini, cannoli, and fresh pasta) and a more "authentic" Italian feel, whereas Malta feels like a historic crossroads of British, Arabic, and Italian influences. For 2026, Malta is the "stress-free" choice, while Sicily is the "grand adventure" choice.