Loading Page...

Was the Sydney monorail profitable?

Sydney's deeply unpopular monorail made its final trip on June 30. And in a classic twist, its last weekend turned out to be unexpectedly profitable. The 25-year-old monorail system has long been known for having low ridership and offering little convenience in its path through the city center.



Historically, the Sydney Monorail was generally considered a financial and practical disappointment, which eventually led to its removal in 2013. While it was a futuristic symbol when it opened in 1988 for the Australian Bicentenary, it never achieved the passenger numbers required to be truly profitable as a standalone transit system. The monorail was criticized for being a "train to nowhere," as its single-loop track primarily served the tourist-heavy Darling Harbour and Chinatown areas but did not integrate well with the broader city rail or bus networks. Maintenance costs for the aging infrastructure and specialized parts were high, and the high ticket prices deterred local commuters. By the time the New South Wales government purchased the system from private owners in 2012, it was seen as an impediment to the redevelopment of the Sydney Convention and Exhibition Centre. The government decided that the cost of upgrading the system was unjustifiable, and it was dismantled to make way for a more efficient light rail network, ending its 25-year run as a quirky but ultimately unfeasible piece of urban infrastructure.

People Also Ask

Switches, for monorail, are huge, cumbersome devices that take many times longer than standard rail switches to actually switch over. The maximum frequency of trains over the bridge would have been choked off by switch actions between every set of trains.

MORE DETAILS

The entire set of the beam, the bogies, the wheels, etc. is more complex and expensive for a monorail. Monorail requires a lot of stuff around the beam, often made of expensive rare metals, with a lot more maintenance. Monorail beam itself must be built and maintained to high specifications.

MORE DETAILS

Monorails lack flexibility and are not really suitable for anything beyond short loop routes. Plus, you're married to the technology of whoever builds the system. Not everyone can build a monorail, yet many manufacturers can make equipment that runs on two rails.

MORE DETAILS

Yes. There are 42 urban monorail systems operating in the world today. Each day they safely shuttle millions of passengers between hundreds of stations with 99.5% reliability -- the highest reliability of any transit mode.

MORE DETAILS

Perhaps the most notable is the 2009 Monorail crash that killed young driver, 21-year-old Austin Wuennenberg.

MORE DETAILS

The cove was called Warrane by the Aboriginal inhabitants. Phillip considered naming the settlement Albion, but this name was never officially used. By 1790 Phillip and other officials were regularly calling the township Sydney.

MORE DETAILS

Nevertheless, closure became government policy in the early 1950s and the system was wound down in stages, with withdrawal of the services completed on 25 February 1961 when R1 class tram 1995 returned from La Perouse to Randwick Workshops just before 4:40pm on 25 February 1961, which was driven by Jerry Valek, a ...

MORE DETAILS

Monorail is, by design, a grade-separated system. They do not interfere with existing transport modes. Unlike conventional rail systems, straddle monorails wrap around their track and are thus not physically capable of derailing, unless the track itself suffers a catastrophic failure.

MORE DETAILS