Green Turtle Cay is a gem of the Abaco Islands in the Bahamas, renowned for its rich Loyalist history and its charming, New England-style aesthetic. The island's main village, New Plymouth, features colorful clapboard cottages and picket fences that make it feel more like a 19th-century fishing village than a typical tropical resort. It is famously the birthplace of Methodism in the Bahamas and is home to the Albert Lowe Museum, which chronicles the island’s heritage through local artifacts and art. Beyond its history, the Cay is a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts, known for its pristine, secluded beaches like Coco Bay and Ocean Beach. The surrounding waters are a hotspot for "bonefishing," reef diving, and snorkeling among vibrant coral formations. Visitors typically navigate the three-mile-long island by golf cart, enjoying a slow-paced lifestyle that revolves around the local marina, fresh seafood at spots like the Green Turtle Club, and the famous Memorial Sculpture Garden honoring the island's founders.