Loading Page...

What is the controversy with the Bronx Zoo?

Bronx Zoo operator apologizes for racist display of African man in 1906. Ota Benga, a Central African man, was put on display in the monkey house in 1906 before Black ministers brought the disgraceful incident to an end, the zoo operator said.



The controversy surrounding the Bronx Zoo primarily centers on its historical treatment of an African man, Ota Benga, in 1906, an incident now widely condemned as a profound example of scientific racism and human degradation.

Here’s a breakdown of the key points of the controversy:

The Ota Benga Incident (1906)

  • Exhibition as an “Exhibit”: Ota Benga, a young Mbuti man from the Congo, was brought to the United States by explorer Samuel Verner. In September 1906, the Bronx Zoo’s director, William Temple Hornaday, placed Benga on “exhibit” in the Monkey House, often with an orangutan. Signs were posted, and he was encouraged to shoot arrows for spectators.
  • Rationale and Racism: Hornaday and others framed this as an “anthropological exhibit,” claiming to show human evolution. In reality, it was a blatant display of Social Darwinism and racism, presenting an African man as a lower evolutionary “link” between apes and white Europeans. It catered to and reinforced the worst racial prejudices of the era.
  • Public Outcry and Aftermath: While some visitors and the press treated it as a curiosity, Black ministers, notably Rev. James H. Gordon, led forceful protests, decrying it as dehumanizing and racist. Due to this pressure, the exhibit ended after just two days, though Benga remained on the zoo grounds for a few more weeks. He was later moved to an orphanage and then to Virginia, where he tragically died by suicide in 1916.

Lasting Impact and Modern Reckoning

The controversy is not just a historical

People Also Ask

In 2006, the Bronx Zoo announced no further elephants would be acquired, a measure taken by other zoos after calls from the public and animal experts stated that elephants do not belong in captivity thus affecting their natural behaviors as social creatures.

MORE DETAILS

Bronx Zoo officials put Ota Benga on display in the zoo's Monkey House for several days during the week of September 8, 1906 before outrage from local Black ministers quickly brought the disgraceful incident to an end.

MORE DETAILS

Today, the Bronx Zoo is world-renowned for its large and diverse animal collection, and its award-winning exhibitions. The zoo is part of an integrated system of four zoos and one aquarium managed by the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS), and it is accredited by the Association of Zoos and Aquariums (AZA).

MORE DETAILS

Zootastic is a troubled roadside zoo that has repeatedly been cited for egregious violations including monkeys who suffered from frostbite, wolves whose ears were being eaten by maggots, animal escapes, animal attacks on humans, inadequate veterinary care and unsafe and unsanitary animal enclosures.

MORE DETAILS

Last Monday, the Bronx Zoo officially closed its 111-year-old Primate (Monkey) House, citing a need for change in the ways the animals are exhibited—an evolution, if you will. Responses have revealed how deeply unsettling the closure is to the general psyche of the City, but with few genuinely able to articulate why.

MORE DETAILS

An escaped peacock from the Bronx Zoo that spent Wednesday night and Thursday morning camping out in a tree in West Farms has returned back home, officials from the zoo say.

MORE DETAILS

Until the 20 th century, there was little or no concern for the welfare of zoo animals. It was not until the late 1970s and early 1980s that the appearance of zoos began to change to reflect the public opinion; this transition took place as people were educated about the true conditions endured by zoo animals.

MORE DETAILS

Controversy. There has been controversy about Safari World for its treatment of animals. Their operation came under international scrutiny when their treatment of animals, particularly orangutans and elephants, and keeping lion and tiger cubs in cramped cages.

MORE DETAILS

Bronx Zoo Gets a Female Yapock, 'Rarest Animal of the Americas'; Captured by Natives in Jungle of Costa Rica -- She Likes Night Life, so Visitors May Find Her Asleep Today. New York Times subscribers* enjoy full access to TimesMachine—view over 150 years of New York Times journalism, as it originally appeared.

MORE DETAILS

The Bronx Zoo It's a bird, it's a giraffe, it's a – New York City skyline! One of the largest zoos in the world, the Bronx Zoo can be found in uptown Manhattan, and that's the subtle focal point of its logo.

MORE DETAILS