Where is the best freshwater fishing on Long Island?

The Carmans River showcases native brook trout, the only trout species native to Long Island.
  • Argyle Lake, Babylon.
  • Artist Lake, Middle Island.
  • Avon Manor Pond, Amityville.
  • Belmont Lake, North Babylon.
  • Blydenburgh Lake, Smithtown.
  • Canaan Lake, North Patchogue.
  • Deep Pond, Wading River.
  • Forge Pond, Calverton.




For the best freshwater fishing on Long Island in 2026, Lake Ronkonkoma stands out as the premier destination. As the island's largest and deepest lake (reaching depths of 65 feet), it support a diverse population of Largemouth and Smallmouth Bass, as well as Chain Pickerel and Walleye. For those seeking a more tranquil experience, Blydenburgh Lake (also known as Stump Pond) in Smithtown is famous for its massive Largemouth Bass and scenic hiking trails. If you are looking for trout, Hempstead Lake State Park and the Carmans River are the top choices, as they are regularly stocked by the NYS Department of Environmental Conservation in the spring and fall. For families, Belmont Lake State Park offers easy shore access and a very high "catch rate" for bluegill and yellow perch. Remember that in 2026, all anglers aged 16 and older still require a valid New York State freshwater fishing license, which can be easily purchased via the official state mobile app.

People Also Ask

Both northern and southern fish species frequent Long Island waters, including Atlantic cod, winter flounder and mackerel in the spring, or bluefish, summer flounder and Spanish mackerel in the fall. Other species of fish include blackfish, porgies, and fluke, in addition to shark, tuna, and abundant striped bass.

MORE DETAILS

Sound decisions Most fish in Long Island Sound are safe to eat except for restrictions on striped bass, bluefish, and weakfish. Striped bass and bluefish over 25 inches should not be eaten by those in the high-risk group and limited to one meal per month by others.

MORE DETAILS

You've heard about the famous white-sand beaches. And the world class wineries, fresh local produce and seafood. Long Island was named one of the world's Top 10 wine regions and boasts top-rated restaurants.

MORE DETAILS