Loading Page...

Who was to blame for Zeebrugge disaster?

A public court of inquiry into the disaster placed the blame on three of the ferry's staff: assistant boatswain Mark Stanley, who failed to close the bow doors after falling asleep in his cabin during a short break; first officer Leslie Sabel, who failed to ensure the bow doors were closed; and captain David Lewry for ...



The Zeebrugge disaster (MS Herald of Free Enterprise) in 1987 was a catastrophic failure of both individual personnel and a toxic corporate culture at Townsend Thoresen (Townsend Car Ferries Ltd.). The official public inquiry, led by Mr. Justice Sheen, famously concluded that the disaster was the result of the "disease of sloppiness" that had infected the entire company "at all levels of management." While the immediate cause of the capsizing was the Assistant Boatswain (Mark Stanley) falling asleep and failing to close the bow doors, the inquiry placed the ultimate blame on the company directors and managers. These managers had consistently ignored repeated warnings from the ship's masters about the dangers of their "speed-at-all-costs" turnaround times and had refused to install simple, low-cost "warning lights" on the bridge that would have alerted the Captain that the doors were open. The Captain (David Lewry) and First Officer (Leslie Sabel) were also faulted for failing to verify the doors were closed before sailing, but the Sheen Report made it clear that they were victims of an incompetent safety management system that lacked clear lines of responsibility.

People Also Ask

Investigation and inquiry While the court determined the immediate cause of the capsizing was Stanley's failure to close the bow doors, it was very critical of Sabel for not being in a position to prevent the disaster, calling his actions the most immediate cause of the capsizing.

MORE DETAILS

A combination of procedural errors and oversights and the design of the ferry itself caused the vehicle deck to flood, after the ferry set sail with the bow doors open.

MORE DETAILS

Mark Stanley, the assistant bosun on the day of the tragedy, died in hospital on July 20, aged 58. He had not closed the bow doors when the ship set sail and he had been haunted by the tragedy, which was said to have severely affected his health, working life and family. Mr Stanley had fallen asleep in his cabin.

MORE DETAILS

The Crown Prosecution Service charged P&O European Ferries with corporate manslaughter in 1989 and seven employees with manslaughter. The case collapsed but it set a precedent for corporate manslaughter being legally admissible in an English court.

MORE DETAILS

Sue and the children were each offered a pounds 5,000 fixed payment for being aboard the Herald of Free Enterprise when it capsized.

MORE DETAILS

Carly Zutic, from Dumfries, Scotland passed away suddenly at her home after a long battle with drug addiction, the Daily Record reported. Carly was just nine weeks old when she survived the sinking of the Herald of Free Enterprise in March 1987.

MORE DETAILS

The history of the port of Zeebrugge goes back to the origins of the city of Bruges: from the creation of the first navigable canals, to the rise of the flourishing economic and cultural centre in the late Middle Ages, to its decline from the 15th century onwards.

MORE DETAILS

The MS Herald of Free Enterprise was a Roll-On Roll-Off (RORO) ferry which capsized moments after leaving the Belgian port of Zeebrugge on the night of March 6, 1987, killing 193 passengers and crew.

MORE DETAILS

Zeebrugge is a city in West-Flanders, Belgium. It has many popular attractions, including St. Donatian's Cathedral, De Fonteintjes, Visserskruis, making it well worth a visit.

MORE DETAILS

MS Free Enterprise (I) was a cross-Channel ferry operated by Townsend Brothers and later Townsend Thoresen between 1962 and 1980. She was their first purpose built roll-on/roll-off passenger and vehicle ferry. She was sold to Greece in 1980, where she served until being sold for scrap in 2013.

MORE DETAILS

The simple answer is: they are generally very safe. In fact, ferries are normally considered one of the safest means to travel in Europe.

MORE DETAILS