The historic Gibraltar Point Lighthouse is located on Hanlan's Point, which is the most westerly of the Toronto Islands. Built in 1808, it is the oldest existing lighthouse on the Great Lakes and one of the oldest buildings in Toronto. In 2026, it remains a popular spot for both history buffs and ghost hunters, as it is famously associated with the legend of its first keeper, John Paul Radelmüller, who was allegedly murdered there in 1815. While the lighthouse is no longer an active navigational aid (having been deactivated in 1956), the structure is beautifully preserved and serves as a landmark for those exploring the islands. Hanlan's Point is also known for its beach and small airport, but the lighthouse stands as a quiet, "haunted" reminder of Toronto's early maritime history, offering a peaceful contrast to the bustling city skyline visible just across the water of Lake Ontario.